Google Maps Competitor Analysis for Local Businesses: Compare Yourself with the Top 3 (2026)
By the Amica Solutions Team · Published 19 November 2026 · Google facts checked 19 November 2026 against Google’s own Help pages. Amica Solutions builds Amica Directory and these free tools, so the screenshots are from our own tools and our own listing.
For Google Maps competitor analysis, search your main keyword from where your customers are and compare the top 3 with you on rating, review count, review freshness, primary category and website. The biggest gap is usually reviews. Copy what is allowed, report keyword-stuffed names, and never copy rule-breaking tricks.
You vs the top 3 (other names blurred by us) and the rank grid, from our own audit. Screenshots: Amica Directory, 19 Nov 2026.
It is easy to feel that the businesses above you are just lucky. Usually they are not; they have more reviews, a sharper category or a better website. A ten-minute comparison shows which.
Key takeaways
- Compare with the top 3 for your real keyword.
- Rating, reviews, freshness, category, website.
- Our gap: 78 reviews vs 406.
- Report keyword-stuffed names; do not copy them.
- The free audit does this comparison for you.
How do you compare yourself with Google Maps competitors?
Search your main keyword on Google Maps from where your customers are, note the top 3 businesses, and compare five things.
| Compare | Where to see it | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|
| Rating | Next to the name | Customer satisfaction |
| Number of reviews | Next to the rating | Prominence; often the biggest gap |
| Newest review date | Reviews tab, sorted by newest | Whether reviews keep coming |
| Primary category | Under the name | Relevance to the keyword |
| Website | Profile buttons | Whether Google can read more about them |
Google says local ranking uses relevance, distance and prominence (Google Business Profile Help). Your comparison shows which of these you are losing on.
What did our own comparison show?
Our own comparison, for “digital marketing company” around our office:
| Business | Rating | Reviews | Website |
|---|---|---|---|
| Amica Solutions (us) | 4.9 | 78 | Yes |
| Competitor A | 4.9 | 406 | Yes |
| Competitor B | 5.0 | 52 | Yes |
| Competitor C | 4.8 | 81 | Yes |
Same rating as the leader, but about one-fifth of the reviews. That told us exactly where to work: a steady flow of new, honest reviews. The report also noticed that two competitors had added keywords to their business names.
You vs the top 3 near you (other businesses’ names blurred by us). Screenshot: Amica Directory, 19 Nov 2026.
What should you copy, and what not?
Copy what is allowed; report what is not. Google’s guidelines say “Including unnecessary information in your business name isn’t permitted” and that address lines should not include keywords (Google guidelines). If a competitor ranks with a keyword-stuffed name, you can suggest an edit on their Maps listing. Do not copy it; a profile can be suspended for it.
Get your top-3 comparison
Free tool: Free Google Business Profile audit
Get your rating, reviews and website compared with the top 3 near you for your keyword, plus a rank grid and an action plan.
Frequently asked questions
How do I find my competitors on Google Maps?
Search your main service keyword on Google Maps from where your customers are; the top 3 results are your real competitors for that search.
What should I compare with competitors?
Rating, number of reviews, how recent their reviews are, primary category and whether they have a website.
Why does a competitor with fewer reviews rank above me?
They may be closer to the searcher, have a better-matched category, or more relevant information. Distance and relevance matter as well as reviews.
Can I report a competitor's keyword-stuffed name?
Yes. Use Suggest an edit on their Maps listing. Google’s guidelines do not allow extra keywords in business names.
Is there a free Google Maps competitor analysis tool?
Yes. The free Amica Directory audit compares you with the top 3 businesses near you for your keyword.
Sources (checked 19 November 2026)





